Canada - English

Security Dealers - Face More GST Challenges and Increased Tax Audits 

Canadian Tax Adviser


February 25, 2014


Despite dealing with many significant tax changes over the last few years, security dealers are still facing new GST/HST and QST challenges. With increased costs for non-compliance such as penalties and increased audit activities by the tax authorities, security dealers must understand and apply all the complex tax rules that apply to their specific facts and circumstances. In addition, many security dealers are still dealing with changes introduced in past years, including significant GST/HST amendments, changes to the CRA's policies, new HST rates and new compliance obligations.

Your business, as a security dealer, may face GST, HST, QST and PST challenges, tax audit queries and possibly even additional tax costs if you:


  • Are required to use the special attribution method (the "SAM" formula, as explained below)
  • Have an office or a branch in British Columbia, Quebec, and Prince Edward Island and has not accounted for related changes to tax costs
  • Are subject to new compliance rules under the new QST rules for financial institutions, which includes a new QST annual information return and the transfer of the administration of the QST accounts of some financial institutions to the CRA (from Revenu Quebec)
  • Did not set up systems and processes to deal with the return to the PST in British Columbia
  • Import services or intangibles into Canada, including financial services from related entities
  • Are a branch and have deductible expenses in Canada for charges from your head office located outside Canada
  • Do not pay GST/HST or QST to certain people who sell your products and who are not regulated to sell your products
  • Have taxable (or zero-rated) supplies as well as exempt supplies and have not reviewed your allocation methodology
  • Have an employees' pension plan.

If you are a security dealer, you must carefully review and understand how the complicated GST/HST rules apply to your business, how the new QST rules affect your operations, and whether you have fulfilled all of your compliance obligations. If you do not fully comply with these rules or make filing mistakes you could be subject to additional taxes, interest or non-compliance penalties or may have overpaid taxes.


Many financial institutions across Canada, including security dealers, are subject to complicated GST/HST rules known as the SAM formula. This formula applies to a financial institution that has a "permanent establishment" in an HST-participating province and in another province, and is used to calculate the amount of the provincial component of the HST (PVAT) payable by the financial institution for all the HST provinces. For security dealers, a permanent establishment is based on whether the security dealer has a fixed place of business such as an office in a province. If a security dealer has a fixed place of business both in a harmonized province and another province, it will be subject to the SAM formula. Quebec has generally incorporated in the QST rules similar SAM rules effective January 1, 2013.


GST/HST and QST checklist - Action items
Here are some important considerations that you should review to determine how they may affect your security dealer business:


  • SAM formula - The SAM formula requires many financial institutions to track all the GST, PVAT and QST paid, and includes many adjustments for specific items including transitional rules and recaptured input tax credits (ITCs). More than 100 pages of related GST/HST regulations effective back to 2010 were passed in 2013, and these calculations have become more complex in 2013 due to the new QST SAM formula, B.C.'s return to the GST and PST and P.E.I.'s new HST. Also, some security dealers have not dealt with all the applicable adjustments effective since 2010, and could have overpaid or underpaid PVAT or be subject to audit by the CRA.
  • Increased QST costs - The new 2013 QST rules for financial institutions will increase operating costs. It is important for security dealers to understand the effect of these new rules on their tax costs and what they can do to help mitigate them.
  • New QST compliance obligations - Security dealers should determine their filing obligations for Quebec's new QST annual information return, which is similar to the GST/HST annual information return. The information on these returns should correspond to other GST/HST, QST and income tax returns. Security dealers should determine whether they have to file both returns (or a combined return, if applicable). These annual returns can come with significant penalties if not filed as required and on time. It appears that the CRA is now assessing these new penalties.
  • B.C.'s return to GST and PST - Many security dealers must now pay B.C. PST on certain purchases and self-assess PST on taxable items brought in the province as a result of B.C.'s elimination of the HST and return to GST and PST in 2013.
  • Self-assessment rules - Under the self-assessment rules for imports, security dealers must self-assess on both taxable imported supplies (i.e., services and intangibles) under the general rules as well as on financial services from related entities and charges from head office under special rules. These special rules require self-assessment for a component of the financial services known as "loading".
  • Intercompany transactions - Security dealers must properly account for GST/HST and QST related to intercompany transactions which can raise many related issues, including fair market value rules, section 150 and other FI related elections, SAM adjustment calculations, allocation between taxable and exempt activities and agency.
  • Exempt "arranging for" services - Security dealers and some of their service providers that rely on the GST/HST exempting provision "arranging for" services should review their agreements to ensure that they meet the exemption provision and that none of the exclusions apply. The GST/HST amendments and a related CRA's administrative bulletin have raised many questions and interpretative issues.
  • GST/HST and QST pension plan rules - Many security dealers have to apply the complex GST/HST and QST pension plan rules. However, the 2013 federal budget included a new relieving measure that could reduce the complexity for some companies.
  • Allocation between taxable and exempt sales - The CRA continues to review security dealers' input allocation between their taxable and zero rated activities, and exempt activities.


We can help
The final GST/HST selected listed financial institution (SLFI) regulations released in 2013 are one of the most significant legislative updates for the industry since the introduction of the GST in the early 1990s. With more than 100 pages of regulations, the GST/HST SLFI rules include significant penalties, complicated calculations, new compliance rules and several transitional rules for various circumstances. The new QST rules and related compliance issues only add to the complexity of indirect taxes for security dealers. We can help you carefully navigate this maze of complicated rules and help you meet your requirements and reduce related compliance and overall tax costs.






Information is current to February 25, 2014. The information contained in this publication is of a general nature and is not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavour to provide accurate and timely information, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate as of the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future. No one should act upon such information without appropriate professional advice after a thorough examination of the particular situation. For more information, contact KPMG's National Tax Centre at 416.777.8500


Canadian companies may be interested in these recent publications: