Australia

Details

  • Service: Tax, Indirect Tax, Dispute Resolution
  • Type: Regulatory update
  • Date: 15/07/2014

Tax Insights

KPMG's analysis of tax issues and developments.

Kate Law

Kate Law
Partner, Indirect Tax

+61 8 9263 7303

katelaw@kpmg.com.au

Dispute settlement: Is there a GST sting in the tail? 

by Kate Law, Indirect Tax Specialist

When Benjamin Franklin said, “by failing to prepare you are preparing to fail”, he may not have been contemplating goods and services tax (GST), but I’m sure he won’t mind me borrowing his words to make my point.

Unfortunately, many companies and their legal counsel have been, or are currently involved in, settling disputes with customers or suppliers. The rise of these disputes are a sign of tougher economic times.

 

It is understandable that GST is often not front of mind when parties negotiate and enter into a settlement. However, where GST is payable on a settlement sum and the settlement deed does not contemplate for an additional amount to be paid on account of GST, 1/11th of the settlement sum could be at risk.

 

Whilst liquidated damages, such as those arising from a breach of contract, may not give rise to a GST liability, some settlements do give rise to GST as they are viewed by the Commissioner as relating to:

 

  • an earlier supply – in which the settlement is consideration for the earlier supply or an adjustment to the price previously paid for the earlier supply
  • a current supply – arising from the terms of the settlement.

 

We have seen settlement deeds which are silent on GST, leaving the victor with a GST liability and no ability to recover it from the other party. In other instances, parties may hope to rely on a standard GST clause to resolve any issues, but these may not cover the full range of scenarios that parties might find themselves in. The GST position of each party should be considered and agreed upfront and appropriate contractual clauses be put in place to ensure that no party is out of pocket on account of GST.

 

You don’t want to be settling one dispute only to find yourself in another!

 

Share this

Share this

Indirect Tax

KPMG can assist in all aspects of indirect tax, from education and training, policy, compliance and technology through to audits and disputes.

Tax Dispute Resolution & Controversy Services

When disputes with revenue authorities arise, KPMG can help by provide efficient, cost effective approach to resolution.