New Thinking
A roadmap for mid-market business owners
Adapting customer loyalty
Australia and the corporate governance experience
Australian and UK rail franchising experiences
Australian Regional Capacity Index
Australia's defence industry and the rise of Asia
Better business reporting – the journey continues
Big Data and why it matters
CHAFTA: Look to China for growth
Chinese Investment in Australia Demystified
Cloud – enabling business strategy
Corporate growth
Critical actions for a positive future
Cyber and digital security
Cyber security – Detect cyber threat
Cyber security – Protect your business
Cyber security – Respond to cyber threats
Cyber security – Secure organisational growth
Digital: A framework for the age of disruption
Digital: Reinventing the customer experience
Digital identity key for unlocking new business
Disrupting the board
Empowering Australians' impacted by their service
Financial reports de-cluttering in ASX200 companies
Financial System Inquiry – Innovation: Digital identity
Financial System Inquiry – Regulatory system
Financial System Inquiry – Superannuation and retirement incomes
Fixing Australia's naval shipbuilding industry
Future of investment management
Global shifts in defence and security
Harnessing the power of disruption
Here comes the M&A boom
Human services: rethinking regulation
Improving cities through urban renewal
Indirect Tax and International Tax – double the trouble?
Infrastructure trends
Leaving leadership development to chance is not worth the risk
Pricing: Defining the right strategy
Promising prospects in Australian corporate finance
Resource sector outlook
Risk transformation: Embracing conscious risk taking
Risk transformation: Engaging the first line of defence
Risk transformation: What makes a great CRO?
Road testing a public service reform agenda
Social media risks
Tax Reform: a call for fundamental change
Tax Reform: a new simplicity for fringe benefits
Tax Reform: a single tax collector
Tax Reform: stopping the fiscal drag
Tax Reform: property services tax
Tax reform – shaping the future
Tax transparency and morality
Technology and growth: working with the 'connected customer'
Technology's impact on investment industry
The constantly changing role of the CIO
The power of population
The private side of public investment
The Road to Paris
Transforming for consumer growth
Urban and regional growth: a smarter way
Utilities: technology is the future
Value of Audit
What is the future for government?
What a Japanese submarine option could mean for Australia
Indirect Tax and International Tax


Indirect Tax and International Tax – double the trouble?

Doing business globally? Then you will be more than aware of the increased international effort to ensure businesses pay their ‘fair share’ of taxes.

The infamous 'Double Irish Dutch Sandwich', which seems to be at the centre of many global tax structures, is perceived to be ‘the root of all evil’ in the international tax world. Whilst those structures comply fully with the national laws of Ireland and the Netherlands, they do rely on the features of the bi-lateral double tax treaty between the two countries, and hence the drive from the OECD and National Governments to change the Double Tax Treaty network.

So let's move the base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS) debate to the goods and services tax (GST) / value added tax (VAT) world. Remember there are no double tax agreements for indirect taxes, so our 'sandwich' could produce an indirect tax rate of 63 percent. Current European Union law prevents the doubling up mentioned above, however, the same cannot be said for other jurisdictions.  

Trading internationally can give rise to many potential indirect tax impacts. Getting it right, however, can lead to
substantial savings.       
The solution to date has always been to register in the offshore jurisdiction and reclaim the tax and consequently live with the administrative burden.

Unsurprisingly, things cannot be that simple. We are now seeing a number of jurisdictions (including Australia) making it increasingly difficult for non residents to get registered, and, in some instances, introducing special rules that can lead to potential double indirect taxation.

Recent case

We recently advised a client who had outsourced their IT support function to a third party, under a single global contract.

As a result of proposed new VAT legislation for e-commerce transactions in South Africa, the third party supplier may be required to charge South African VAT at 14 percent on the services to the South African subsidiary. The legislation is being introduced to combat what the South African Government sees as tax lost on supplies consumed in country, which they cannot effectively tax any other way.

However, as the cost is billed to the Australian head office, which recovers it with a range of other costs by way of a management fee, Head Office is not currently registered for VAT in South Africa, and under the equivalent of the Australian legislative "connected with" provisions, would not be entitled to register. Head Office would not itself be providing digital services so the new legislation would not apply to it. If the legislation is enacted as drafted, the VAT cost on the business process outsourcing (BPO) provider fee will not be recoverable.

While we delivered a great result for them it did open up our eyes to what many other organisations are facing.

So while you consider your position under the BEPS debate from a corporate income tax position, it is becoming increasingly evident you should not neglect the many potential indirect tax impacts.

Share this

Share this

Video: Indirect tax and big data

Video: Indirect tax and big data
Dermot Gaffney, Indirect Tax, KPMG Australia and Tim Gillis, KPMG's Global Head of Indirect Tax, talk indirect tax and big data.

Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS)

Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS)
Are companies paying their 'fair share' of tax? KPMG addresses the Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) debate.

Tax transparency and morality

Tax transparency and morality
Societal concern about tax transparency and morality has lead to intense political debate and is driving international tax reform.

Indirect Tax

KPMG can assist in all aspects of indirect tax, from education and training, policy, compliance and technology through to audits and disputes.